Anita Earls for NC Supreme Court – PA PAC endorses Anita Earls for the North Carolina Supreme Court. Earls’ legal training and experience make her ideally suited to serve on our state’s highest court. She holds degrees from the country’s very best schools where she earned highest honors. She was editor of the Yale Law Review. She worked as a civil rights attorney with the Ferguson-Stein law firm, one of North Carolina’s leading civil rights firms for ten years. She then worked in the Civil Rights Division of the United States Department of Justice in Washington during the Clinton Administration. She has taught law at the University of Maryland, Duke, and UNC. At UNC she was the director of the Center for Civil Rights. She was the founder and first director of the Southern Coalition for Social Justice. Usually, we do not go over a candidate’s resume in detail like this, but for the Supreme Court, serious legal scholarship is very important. The court’s authority is reposed in it.
Earls’ responses to our questionnaire indicate that she is personally aligned with PA’s views on policy questions. As a Supreme Court Justice, however, she repeatedly cautioned that she will apply the law scrupulously.
Earls is African-American. Only six African-Americans have ever served on the North Carolina Supreme Court in its more than 200-year history.
Most people know Anita Earls from her tireless advocacy for the poor, for people of color, for the disfranchised, for the LGBTQ community, and marginalized people everywhere. The best recent example of her work is her role as lead attorney in Dickson v. Rucho, the case which challenged and overcame the Republican legislature’s racially gerrymandered legislative districts. The litigation lasted six years and went to the United States Supreme Court twice.
Earls is a Democrat. Her principal opponent in the contest is the Republican incumbent, Barbara Jackson. Justice Jackson chose not to participate in PA PAC’s endorsement process. It is important to note that Jackson voted with the court’s majority to uphold the racially gerrymandered districts in the Rucho case on two occasions. Each time, the court’s decision was overturned by the US Supreme Court through Anita Earls’ advocacy.
The other Republican candidate, Christopher James Anglin, did not respond to our invitation to participate in our endorsement process. His candidacy has been controversial because he switched his party affiliation from Democrat to Republican before filing.
John Arrowood for NC Court of Appeals – PA PAC backs Judge John Arrowood for the North Carolina Court of Appeals. Judge Arrowood obtained his law degree from UNC law school in 1982. After graduation, he was a staff attorney for the NC Court of Appeals and rose to become staff director. He was also selected to clerk for the Chief Judge of the court. Appellate court staff and clerk positions are honors reserved for the very best legal scholars. With Arrowood’s years of service, few candidates could be more familiar with the business of the court.
After working for the court, Arrowood worked for nearly thirty years in a broad range of civil practice. His criminal practice was concentrated on post-conviction expunctions and pardons. He has also served as a Special Superior Court Judge at the trial level. Arrowood has been a member of the board of the North Carolina Railroad, the NC Banking Commission, the NC Rules Review Commission, and the NC Arts Council. He is truly committed to public service.
Arrowood has served on the Court of Appeals twice, both through appointments. The first occasion was 2007-8. The most recent followed his appointment in 2017. On a number of occasions, he has dissented from the majority only to have his view of the case adopted by the NC Supreme Court on appeal.
Responses to judicial questionnaires are often guarded. From Judge Arrowood’s questionnaire, it appears that his policy views are aligned with PA’s. He cited cases relating to voting rights and the separation of powers as among the most significant recent decisions of the courts. He is concerned about the legislature’s partisan manipulation of seats on the Court of Appeals and with vacancy appointments.
Judge Arrowood is a Democrat and is the incumbent for this seat. He is the first openly gay person to serve on either of NC’s appellate courts.
Andrew Heath, Arrowood’s Republican opponent, chose not to respond to our invitation to participate in our endorsement process. He was budget director in Governor McCrory’s administration and was then appointed to the Industrial Commission. He now serves as a superior court judge.
Toby Hampson for NC Court of Appeals – PA PAC endorses Toby Hampson for the NC Court of Appeals seat being vacated by Anne Marie Calabria.
Hampson has a Durham connection. He graduated from the North Carolina School of Science and Mathematics. He is an honors graduate of the American University in Washington, DC, and from Campbell University law school. Following graduation from law school, Hampson clerked for three judges on the NC Court of Appeals. In private practice, he has concentrated on appellate work and is now head of appellate practice for one of the state’s most prominent law firms. He is an expert in the business of our appellate courts.
Hampson’s questionnaire responses indicate that he agrees with PA on policy issues. He has well-developed views about improving access to the courts and for simplified and less expensive resolution of routine and minor matters. He supports diversion programs and adequate funding for indigent defense. He indicated a desire to use his position as a judge to advocate for equal access to the courts and to address racial disparities in the judicial system. He cited the City of Asheville case in the NC Supreme Court as having special significance because in it the court reasserted its authority and obligation to review legislative acts as a check on the power of the General Assembly.
Hampson is a Democrat. Opposing him are Republicans Jefferson Griffin and Sandra Ray. Both are serving as trial court judges. Ray declined to participate in our endorsement process. Griffin appeared at our candidate mixer and was interviewed. He did not, however, respond to our questionnaire. He lost to Lauren Freeman for the office of Wake County DA back in 2014.
Allegra Collins for NC Court of Appeals – PA PAC endorses Allegra Collins for the Elmore Seat on the North Carolina Court of Appeals. Collins grew up in Virginia and was a champion tennis player during her college years. Before attending Campbell Law School, she played professional tennis for a time and worked in the business world. Following graduation, Collins clerked in the Court of Appeals and later worked in the office of the appellate reporter for the NC Supreme Court. She holds a faculty position in legal research and writing at Campbell Law School and has her own successful appellate practice. She represents indigent criminal defendants at the appellate level. Like candidates Hampson and Arrowood, Collins is an expert in appellate advocacy and the business of our appellate courts.
Her responses to our questionnaire on policy issues were guarded. In her interview, she was less guarded. When she did respond substantively, her answers were aligned with PA’s policy views. She indicated a real concern about access to the courts for people with limited means. She is determined to fight against racial bias in the justice system. She wants to remove political maneuvering in the court system and to protect the role of the North Carolina Supreme Court as the highest court in the state.
Allegra Collins is a Democrat. Her Republican opponent, Chuck Kitchen, served for many years as Durham County attorney. His questionnaire responses are extremely guarded. During his interview, he explained that he changed his voter registration to Republican because of what he perceived to be the Obama administration’s persecution of the Alamance County Sheriff for alleged racial and ethnic profiling.
Michael Monaco, the libertarian candidate, did not respond to our invitation to participate in our endorsement process.